August 31, 2004 By Steven Mirkin
Variety
David Byrne is no stranger to high-end concert halls: He's trod
the board at Carnegie Hall, London's Royal Festival Hall and the
Santa Fe Opera House. But as the leader of the first full-sized
pop band in the Disney Concert Hall, he seemed a little tentative
stepping onto the stage. For this tour he's paired strings with
a rhythm section of bass, guitar and two percussionists -- a surprisingly
flexible combination that works, capturing the airy complexity of
his current disc "Grown Backwards" (Nonesuch) while smartly
reconstructing earlier Talking Heads material. But the acoustics
of the room proved problematic.
Even with the riser behind the stage curtained to keep the sound
from reflecting, the room is still too lively for an amplified band.
The six-piece Tosca Strings were unmiked, the percussionists performed
behind soundproof panels while Byrne's vocals, his guitar and Paul
Frazier's bass and various samples of loops went through the PA.
This created an odd juxtaposition, making the sound mix something
of a work in progress throughout the evening.
Byrne's guitar was inaudible for the driving "I Zimbra"
and turned up too loud during the cleverly rearranged "Psycho
Killer," with the strings aping the song's signature bassline
in counterpoint to Mauro Refosco's melodic marimba. The bass was
particularly troublesome; whether meek or booming, the instrument
lacked definition, the sound muddy and thudding. Only toward the
end of the 21/4-hour show did the balance seem right, resulting
in a thrilling "What a Day It Was" and what Byrne called
a "live remix" of "Lazy," both of which received standing ovations from the soldout house.
The most intriguing music of the evening came when the strings left
the stage. With Refosco on parade drum and Graham Hawthorne on triangle, "Nothing but Flowers" became pure rhythm; they returned
to their kits and transformed the sermon of "Once in a Lifetime" into a lively Carnivale march. It's
hard to tell what the sound was like onstage: There were no monitors;
instead, the musicians wore ear buds to hear themselves.
Byrne was polite as always, dancing around the stage with the exaggerated,
almost ritualized movements he's favored since 1984's "Stop
Making Sense," mixing humor with anecdotes about the songs,
even allowing a "friend of a friend" of the band to take
the stage to propose to his girlfriend. (She accepted.)
It might be too early to tell after this show, but Disney Concert
Hall may be a tough sell to touring bands accustomed to heavy amplification.
It would be interesting to invite sonically experimental musicians
-- such as Byrne, Tom Waits, Bjork or electronic musicians Autrechere
and Paul Van Dyk -- to create site-specific perfs that use the
room's tricky acoustics.
© Copyright 2004 Variety. All Rights Reserved
|